Mar 8, 2011

The Piper's Son - Interview with Melina Marchetta

Happy Book Birthday to Melina today! I was so excited to be asked to host a little Q&A with her. I have heard nothing but great things about her and her work.

Your first novel, Looking For Alibrandi, was also adapted into a movie which you also wrote. A part from the obvious, how was writing the novel different than writing the screenplay?
If you had to include everything in a novel it would literally be a five hour plus film. Film scripts in Australia can’t really be over 105 minutes because of budget, so obviously something has to give and usually it’s someone’s favourite scene or character. The other thing is that what a reader sometimes falls in love with is the character’s first person voice (think Alibrandi, Francesca, Jellicoe) and the first thing that has to go out the window in a film script is the character’s narrative voice so I have to find a way of capturing it through visuals, dialogue etc. Sometimes voice over works but you can’t have a film script with wall to wall voice over.

How does living in Sydney, Australia affect your writing?
Well it’s good for it and bad for it. If I’m writing a fantasy novel, I can’t really get into from my inner city world. For Finnikin I travelled to the Dordogne area of France and for Froi I visited Cappadocia Turkey (and other parts, but Cappadocia has the greatest impact). With the three urban novels, Alibrandi, Francesca, and  The Piper’s Sonthey are all set in my suburb or neighbouring suburb or pretty much the school I taught at for ten years. I remember promising my publisher after showing her first draft that I’d work on the setting in the second draft of The Piper’s Son and she just said, ‘It’s all there.’  Jellicoe was the hardest to write location wise because I didn’t have a set idea of where that was, but in my heart it’s the Riverina area of NSW.

Describe your current novel, The Piper's Son, in three words:
A love story

The Piper's Son takes place years after Saving Francesca. Why that amount of time and why choose Thomas as the main character?
I don’t plan what I’m going to do in a couple of years. I wait for the character to come to me and in 2008, exactly five years after Francesca, Tom came. I remember the exact moment and I’ve never remembered the exact moment of a character coming to me before. At first I sent him away because I didn’t think Tom was big enough a character for his own novel, but he was very persistent. Thank God. I’m going to cheat now and expand on my three words of the previous question. The Piper’s Son is a love story between men, women, guys, girls, brothers, sisters, aunts, nephews, mothers and sons, fathers and sons, grandparents, grandchildren etc etc. It really is an ode to love and all the fury and disappointment that comes with it.

Was it important to write The Piper's Son as a stand alone for those who hadn't read Saving Francesca? Intentional?
Because I was introducing a whole new bunch of family members and because Frankie and the gang were out of school and uni, I didn’t think it was important to constantly refer to the past and what happened at school. I love the fact that people are reading The Piper’s Son first and going back to see what the friends were like when they were seventeen.

The characters go through some pretty heavy and heartbreaking stuff. Do those scenes come easily for you? Do you cry right along with them?
Structurally this was the easiest novel to write (especially after Finnikin and Jellicoe) but emotional, I have to be honest that it was pretty crushing at times.  Because it’s dealing with grief, it was so important that the Finch Mackees had a warped sense of humour and the novel ends with so much hope.  I can’t and won’t write without hope. I’d rather never write again. Strangely, I think it’s my funniest novel.

I've heard nothing but great reviews for The Piper's Son. How do you, as a writer, handle negative reviews?
The same way many people handle negativity. Badly. Pathetically. Slightly teary. With fury. With great pretense that it’s nothing. People tell me not to read them but I’m attracted to them like a deer to headlights. Some criticism is fine because it’s obvious that the reader didn't connect with the novel and you can’t do anything about that. But others have an awful tone to them and I find myself constructing letters in my head in response, but I never go through with writing them. The ones I like least are when a reviewer or blogger makes blanket statements about the plot having holes. If there’s a hole in my plot, I want the specifics, not generalisations.

Any specials plans for your release day?
I’ll be in LA at the time with a friend who lives there (she directed Alibrandi) and then I’m flying to Boston to see my publishers at Candlewick and then it’s New York where I’ll be part of David Levithan’s Teen Writers Festival from the 14-20, March so that will be fun. You can find the schedule on Facebook. I’m very unfamiliar with US readers except through letters and blogs, so it will be interesting.

Thank you, Melina!

The NYC Teen Author Festival Schedule can be found HERE

You can find Melina at her website and Facebook
Add The Piper's Son to Goodreads


  1. Great interview :) I recently bought a copy of Looking for Alibrandi. Can't wait to read it!

  2. Awesome interview. How wonderful that she was able to write the script for the movie adaption of one of her books. I've heard nothing but great things about her writing I need to get this one soon! :)

  3. Great interview! Thanks for posting!

  4. Great interview!! I'm realllly looking forward to reading this book! I didn't know about the others though! Adding all to my wishlist. :)

  5. Very cool interview! I keep hearing great things about this book. I may need to pick up the others & read them soon :-)

  6. Did Beth Revis just comment? It must me MY birthday! *dies* I love this literary life!

  7. Great review! I love the cover and hello 3 words A love story!

  8. Wonderful interview! And I MUST take this opp to stump for this author - I read Saving Francesca (destroyed and lifted me back up - I am Francesca), and The Piper's Son one after the other - you MUST read these books, they are amazing! Her writing. . . . no words for it.

  9. Really enjoyed the interview! Love all of Melina Marchetta's books. :D
    I wish I lived in NY! I would love to be there for the festival. :'(

  10. Brilliant interview. I truly love this author, so learning more about her is fun. I think what was so great about The Piper's Son was that even the purest love can be tough to accept, especially when trying to find a way to love yourself.

  11. Thanks for this interview! I love that you got the chance to write both the book and the screenplay, and were able to see the differences that come with the style of writing.

    Also, I was in Sydney in January! I should've visited you! :)

  12. Loved the interview! And, love Melina Marchetta! The Piper's Son was a brilliant novel and I loved hearing from MM!! Thanks for the awesome interview!

  13. Awesome interview, looks like a great book.

  14. Thanks Melina and Jen. I am currently reading Frankie and I just got The Piper's Son about 10 minutes ago! Yay! I don't think I'm going to sleep tonight. :)